When to Hire Permanent vs. Interim in Food Manufacturing
Your Technical Manager hands in their notice on a Monday morning. There's a BRCGS audit eight weeks out, a customer visit before that, and a quality management system only one person on site properly understands. By Monday afternoon, you're already behind.
Production has its own version. A shift manager goes off sick with no return date. A supervisor steps up to cover, and three weeks later that supervisor is taking calls from an agency, because the extra responsibility arrived without the extra money.
Both situations force the same decision. Do you run a permanent search and live with the gap, bring in an interim, or do both at once?
When to Hire Permanent vs. Interim in Food Manufacturing
What you get from a permanent hire
A permanent Production or Technical Manager is an investment in how your site runs in two years' time, not just next month. They'll learn how your lines run, your product range and your people. They'll build the retailer relationships that earn you some benefit of the doubt when something goes wrong. And they'll develop and mentor the team underneath them, which is where a lot of sites lose ground without noticing.
Permanent hiring makes sense when the role belongs to your long-term structure and cultural fit matters as much as technical capability. It also assumes you can absorb the wait.
The wait is the part most hiring managers underestimate. Brief, search, shortlist, two interview stages, offer – then a notice period that's routinely three months at manager level in food manufacturing. From first conversation to first day on site, four to five months is normal. That's an audit cycle. That's most of a peak season.
Where interim earns its place
Interim managers do a very different job. The good ones in food and drink are career contractors rather than people between permanent roles. They've stabilised struggling sites and walked into failing audits before, across a dozen different businesses, so they arrive with a mental checklist instead of a learning curve.
They also arrive quickly. Because we speak to interim professionals across the industry every day, we usually know who's available and who suits your kind of site before you've finished briefing us. On the interim side, shortlists in hours rather than weeks are normal.
Interim tends to be the right call for an unexpected resignation with something big already in the diary, for maternity or long-term sickness cover, for a capital project or a new line commissioning, and for a site that needs turning round before you hire permanently into it. That last one matters more than people expect. Recruiting a permanent Production Manager into a struggling operation is harder than recruiting into a stable one, and you'll pay for the difference in salary or in time.
Shift coverage is its own problem
The Technical Manager role comes with named responsibility. HACCP team leadership, supplier approval, specification sign-off, the audit trail your customers ask to see. An empty technical chair is a compliance exposure as well as a workload problem, and retailers notice.
An experienced interim Technical Manager will hold the standard and get you through an audit. What they can't do in twelve weeks is rebuild the trust that a long-standing technical relationship gives you with a major customer. So the interim buys you product safety, and the permanent search buys you the relationship. Run them in that order and you protect both.
Technical Managers carry a different kind of risk
The Technical Manager role comes with named responsibility. HACCP team leadership, supplier approval, specification sign-off, the audit trail your customers ask to see. An empty technical chair is a compliance exposure as well as a workload problem, and retailers notice.
An experienced interim Technical Manager will hold the standard and get you through an audit. What they can't do in twelve weeks is rebuild the trust that a long-standing technical relationship gives you with a major customer. So the interim buys you product safety, and the permanent search buys you the relationship. Run them in that order and you protect both.
Most sites end up doing both
Putting an interim on site within a fortnight keeps the operation safe. It also lets you run the permanent search at a sensible pace, which is where the real value shows up. You interview better when you're not desperate. You negotiate better too.
The beauty of this approach is its flexibility. While an interim manager provides stability, there’s no rush to transition if the fit is right. Many sites choose to keep a high-performing interim in place long-term to maintain momentum, while others eventually use that breathing room to transition to a permanent hire at their own pace.
One thing on IR35
If you're hiring interim managers, status determination is part of the job, and getting it wrong is expensive. The risk usually falls on you as the end client. We handle IR35 assessments and documentation as standard on interim placements, so compliance doesn't become another thing on your list.
Let's work out which one you need
If you've got a gap coming, planned or otherwise, have a conversation before you commit to one route. We recruit permanent and interim managers across Operations, Technical, Engineering, NPD, Supply Chain and Commercial, and food and drink manufacturing is the only sector we work in.
Call the team on 0161 399 1575 or email info@truenorthtalent.co.uk, and we'll tell you straight which route fits your needs, honestly.
Reach out to us.
Get in touch with us.
Use this form to send us a message, and we'll get back to you shortly.
Amy Griffith
Managing Director
Amy Griffith is Managing Director of True North Talent and a leading specialist in Food and Drink Manufacturing recruitment, with 8 years’ experience in permanent and interim hiring, executive search and talent strategy, supporting organisations and senior leaders across the UK food, drink and manufacturing sectors.
Latest Insights
Explore our latest market insights on all things food and drink manufacturing.
How specialist recruiters reduce downtime across critical site leads and technical roles
Your Engineering Manager resigns on a Friday afternoon. By Monday you've briefed three agencies. By Wednesday you're looking at twenty-two CVs, and eighteen of them have never set foot in a food environment. You've now lost most of a week and you're no closer to filling the role. The line is still running, the planned maintenance schedule is already slipping, and your Operations Manager has picked up a second job on top of their own. This is the point where the difference between a generalist agency and a specialist recruiter stops being a procurement preference and starts costing you output.
The true cost of a bad hire and why Food Manufacturers are struggling to hire middle-management roles
A new Shift Manager starts in March. By June the pattern is clear. Changeovers are taking longer than they used to, the paperwork lands late more often than not, and two of your stronger line leaders have started asking about roles at the site down the road. Nobody has done anything obviously wrong. The operation is just running worse than it was. That's what a bad hire in middle management usually looks like. It rarely announces itself, and it almost never shows up as a single event you can point at. It gets worse over time, and by the time you've named the problem you've lost six months.
When to Hire Permanent vs. Interim in Food Manufacturing
Your Technical Manager hands in their notice on a Monday morning. There's a BRCGS audit eight weeks out, a customer visit before that, and a quality management system only one person on site properly understands. By Monday afternoon, you're already behind. Production has its own version. A shift manager goes off sick with no return date. A supervisor steps up to cover, and three weeks later that supervisor is taking calls from an agency, because the extra responsibility arrived without the extra money. Both situations force the same decision. Do you run a permanent search and live with the gap, bring in an interim, or do both at once?
How specialist recruiters reduce downtime across critical site leads and technical roles
Your Engineering Manager resigns on a Friday afternoon. By Monday you've briefed three agencies. By Wednesday you're looking at twenty-two CVs, and eighteen of them have never set foot in a food environment. You've now lost most of a week and you're no closer to filling the role. The line is still running, the planned maintenance schedule is already slipping, and your Operations Manager has picked up a second job on top of their own. This is the point where the difference between a generalist agency and a specialist recruiter stops being a procurement preference and starts costing you output.
The true cost of a bad hire and why Food Manufacturers are struggling to hire middle-management roles
A new Shift Manager starts in March. By June the pattern is clear. Changeovers are taking longer than they used to, the paperwork lands late more often than not, and two of your stronger line leaders have started asking about roles at the site down the road. Nobody has done anything obviously wrong. The operation is just running worse than it was. That's what a bad hire in middle management usually looks like. It rarely announces itself, and it almost never shows up as a single event you can point at. It gets worse over time, and by the time you've named the problem you've lost six months.
When to Hire Permanent vs. Interim in Food Manufacturing
Your Technical Manager hands in their notice on a Monday morning. There's a BRCGS audit eight weeks out, a customer visit before that, and a quality management system only one person on site properly understands. By Monday afternoon, you're already behind. Production has its own version. A shift manager goes off sick with no return date. A supervisor steps up to cover, and three weeks later that supervisor is taking calls from an agency, because the extra responsibility arrived without the extra money. Both situations force the same decision. Do you run a permanent search and live with the gap, bring in an interim, or do both at once?
info@truenorthtalent.co.uk
0161 399 1575
Orega Serviced Offices,
1 Balloon Street,
Manchester,
M4 4BE
Company Registration: 14987603
VAT Number: 449301888
